In Java SE 17, both interfaces and abstract classes are used to achieve abstraction, a core principle of object-oriented programming. However, they serve different purposes and have distinct characteristics that influence their use in application design.
Abstract Classes
- Definition: An abstract class is a class that cannot be instantiated on its own and may contain both abstract and concrete methods. Abstract methods within an abstract class are declared without an implementation, and it is the responsibility of the subclass to provide concrete implementations for these methods.
- Method Implementation: Abstract classes allow for both abstract methods (without an implementation) and concrete methods (with an implementation). This enables an abstract class to provide a partial implementation of its functionality.
- State Holding: Abstract classes can hold state (fields) and can have constructors, allowing for more comprehensive encapsulation of behavior and state.
- Inheritance: A class can extend only one abstract class due to Java's single inheritance model, which can be limiting if a class needs to inherit behavior from multiple sources.
- Use Case: Abstract classes are suitable when there is a strong relationship between the abstract class and its subclasses, and when shared state or methods with implementations are needed.
Interfaces
- Definition: An interface in Java is a reference type that can contain only constants, method signatures, default methods, static methods, and nested types. Interfaces cannot contain instance fields. The classes that implement interfaces must provide implementations for the interface's abstract methods.
- Method Implementation: Prior to Java 8, interfaces could contain only abstract method declarations. Since Java 8, interfaces can also contain default methods with an implementation, and static methods with a body. This allows for a certain degree of implementation sharing.
- State Holding: Interfaces cannot hold state. They can declare constants (public static final fields), but they cannot have instance fields.
- Multiple Implementations: A class can implement multiple interfaces, overcoming the single inheritance constraint of abstract classes. This allows for more flexible design and the combination of disparate functionalities.
- Use Case: Interfaces are ideal for defining a contract that various classes can implement, allowing for a decoupled system where the implementation can vary independently from the interface.
Key Differences
- Implementation Flexibility: Interfaces provide more flexibility through multiple implementations, whereas abstract classes are more restrictive due to single inheritance.
- State and Constructors: Abstract classes can have instance variables and constructors, while interfaces cannot.
- Method Types: Abstract classes can have a mix of method types (abstract, static, final), whereas interfaces have abstract methods, and since Java 8, can also have static and default methods, but all are implicitly public.
- Design Intent: Abstract classes are used when subclasses share a common behavior that can be defined or partially implemented by the abstract class. Interfaces are used to define a contract that classes can implement, promoting a clear separation between the contract and its various implementations.
Choosing between an interface and an abstract class in Java SE 17 depends on the specific design needs, considering factors like the relationship among the classes, the need for multiple inheritance, state encapsulation, and the extent of implementation sharing.
An abstract class can have instance methods that implement a default behavior. An Interface can only declare constants and instance methods, but cannot implement default behavior and all methods are implicitly abstract.
An interface has all public members and no implementation. An abstract class is a class which may have the usual flavors of class members (private, protected, etc.), but has one or more abstract methods.